SD-WAN vs. MPLS: Exploring the Benefits and Drawbacks

SD-WAN is a decentralized and efficient network solution that is rapidly gaining traction in corporate network technology. According to Gartner's 2019 research, SD-WAN is poised to become a mainstream technology with a growth rate of up to 30.8 percent and is expected to displace MPLS technology in corporate network systems.

While MPLS technology still dominates corporate networks, it has some drawbacks, including higher network bandwidth costs. As a result, companies should consider SD-WAN solutions as they offer more benefits than MPLS.

To evaluate which solution is best for your company, it's essential to understand the differences between SD-WAN and MPLS, as well as the advantages and disadvantages of each. Learn more in the article below.

Comparing MPLS vs SD-WAN

MPLS is a hardware-based technique for routing data network traffic. MPLS high-performance networks route data from one network node to the next based on short path labels, avoiding complex lookups in routing tables. Additionally, MPLS can encapsulate packets of various data types, including voice and video communications. 

Where SD-WAN is a software-defined wide area network, this solution facilitates an internet connection with a two-point connection, making it more flexible to use with different networks such as wired or wireless.

Calculating the Benefits and Risks of MPLS 

MPLS is usually suitable for traditional structured network systems that use WAN connections specifically for data centers, as MPLS provides application access and security inspection. In addition, MPLS also provides a reliable WAN connection equipped with a guaranteed System Level Agreement (SLA) by the operator and Quality of Service (QoS) enforcement that ensures application traffic is prioritized based on this SLA.

MPLS networks that rely on dedicated WAN connections tend to be expensive, as they require a connection to a data center. It can also cause cloud and SaaS application access delays, resulting in poor user service. MPLS networks also utilize separate routers and security devices to optimize connections, which can increase operational costs and complexity.

The Ups and Downs of SD-WAN

SD-WAN works by decentralizing the WAN network, utilizing low-cost broadband with a direct internet connection that allows users to connect to applications hosted in data centers, cloud services, or SaaS. SD-WAN also enables traffic intelligence based on SLA to provide the maximum end-user experience and can enhance application cybersecurity. In addition, SD-WAN also offers centralized management that automates network operations and provides better visibility into network and application performance. 

However, while SD-WAN enables digital transformation and cloud adoption, in some cases, require experienced IT staff to migrate traditional architecture networks. The process of configuring this business to have effective and maximize results may have additional costs and complexity.

Which Is Better, SD-WAN or MPLS?

After knowing the advantages and disadvantages of each solution, it can be concluded that SD-WAN provides more advantages than MPLS in terms of end user experience, visibility, and flexibility. 

What other advantages does SD-WAN offer compared to MPLS?

Greater Performance Compared to MPLS

SD-WAN provides carrier-independent WAN connectivity, enabling services such as MPLS, broadband, and 5G/LTE to be added to the hub of the network. This provides WAN redundancy and failover by proactively recovering network connections and performance degradations and resulting in an optimal end-user experience for all applications. 

Network SLA policies can direct application traffic, thereby enabling direct access to the cloud and SaaS applications, reducing delays, and further increasing performance. In addition, the flexibility to replace MPLS with transport such as broadband and 5G provides more bandwidth availability, which provides a better user experience. 

In contrast to SD-WAN, MPLS offers a special link with limited bandwidth to work optimally to access critical personal or business applications hosted in the data center. MPLS also fails to meet traffic requests from distributed SaaS and cloud applications at this time. Lack of bandwidth to provide redundancy, failover, and access to data center backhaul applications leads to poor performance and a degraded user experience.

ROI and Cost of SD-WAN vs MPLS

SD-WAN solutions excel by providing built-in capabilities that include routers, traffic engineering, QoS, cybersecurity, and centralized management. SD-WAN also expands its capabilities in switching, wireless, and 5G delivered on the same device. This integrated solution eliminates many different hardware products and management solutions, thereby reducing costs significantly. 

In addition, SD-WAN has visibility capabilities, provides automatic configuration, and Artificial Intelligence for Operations (AIOps) can reduce the time to solve and resolve problems, resulting in a better ROI. 

MPLS networks can be very expensive based on the SLA bandwidth, speed, and performance requirements. MPLS WAN links can create points of failure while adding redundant connections to increase availability, which can lead to significantly greater cost and complexity. The centralized architecture system causes delays in accessing cloud and SaaS applications, resulting in a poor user experience.

Overview of SASE and SD-WAN

In addressing SD-WAN migration issues, enterprises are increasingly adopting Secure Access Service Edge (SASE) as a solution that unifies security and networking into one cloud-delivered solution to enable today's hybrid workforce and application needs. 

SD-WAN works as a network construct for SASE solutions by providing the means to modernize and consolidate security into a single service by simplifying migration to SASE solutions.

Get Prisma SD-WAN from Palo Alto Network Only on Virtus 

It's time to use Palo Alto's Prisma SD-WAN solution to protect your corporate network. Prisma SD-WAN comes with solutions to provide the best security and networking for your company network and is proven to save operational costs by up to 243 percent. 

Virtus as the official value-added distributor of Palo Alto, will help your business take advantage of Prisma SD-WAN solutions starting from the consultation, migration, implementation, and maintenance stages. A professional and Virtus-certified IT team will assist with technical issues 24/7. Click here to chat and consult with Virtus team about Prisma SD-WAN.

 

Writer: William Wong 

Content Writer CTI Group

Share to:

Privacy Policy

PT Virtus Technology Indonesia (“VTI” or “us”) is strongly committed to ensuring that your privacy is protected as utmost importance to us. https://www.virtusindonesia.com/, we shall govern your use of this website, including all pages within this website (collectively referred to herein below as this “Website”), we want to contribute to providing a safe and secure environment for visitors.The following are terms of privacy policy (“Privacy Policy”) between you (“you” or “your”) and VTI. By accessing the website, you acknowledge that you have read, understood and agree to be bound by this Privacy Policy.
Use of The Subscription Service by VTI and Our Customers
When you request information from VTI and supply information that personally identifies you or allows us to contact you, you agree to disclose that information with us. VTI may disclose such information for marketing, promotional and activity only for the purpose of VTI and the Website.
Collecting Information
You are free to explore the Website without providing any personal information about yourself. When you visit the Website or register for the subscription service, we provide some navigational information for you to fill out your personal information to access some content we offered.VTI may collect your personal data such as your name, email address, company name, phone number and other information about yourself or your business. We are collecting your data in some ways, online and offline. VTI collects your data online using features of social media, email marketing, website, and cookies technology. We may collect your data offline in events like conference, gathering, workshop, etc. However, we will not use or disclose those informations with third party or send unsolicited email to any of the addresses we collect, without your express permission. We ensure that your personal identities will only be used in accordance with this Privacy Policy.
How VTI Use the Collected Information
VTI use the information that is collected only in compliance with this privacy policy. Customers who subscribe to our subscription services are obligated through our agreements with them to comply with this Privacy Policy.
In addition to the uses of your information, we may use your personal information to:
Improve your browsing experience by personalizing the websites and to improve the subscription services.
Send information about VTI.
Promote our services to you and share promotional and informational content with you in accordance with your communication preferences.Send information to you regarding changes to our customers’ terms of service, Privacy Policy (including the cookie policy), or other legal agreements
Cookies Technology
Cookies are small pieces of data that the site transfers to the user’s computer hard drive when the user visits the website. Cookies can record your preferences when visiting a particular site and give the advantage of identifying the interest of our visitor for statistical analysis of our site. This information can enable us to improve the content, modifying and making our site more user friendly.Cookies were used for some reasons such as technical reasons for our website to operate. Cookies also enable us to track and target the interest of our users to enhance the experience of our website and subscription service. This data is used to deliver customized content and promotions within the VTI to customers who have an interest on particular subjects.You have the right to decide whether to accept or refuse cookies. You can edit your cookies preferences on browser setup. If you choose to refuse the cookies, you may still use our website though your access to some functionality and areas of our website may be restricted.This Website may also display advertisements from third parties containing links to other websites of interest. Once you have used these links to leave our site, please note that we do not have any control over the website. VTI cannot be responsible for the protection and privacy of any information that you provide while visiting such websites and this Privacy Policy does not govern such websites.
Control Your Personal Data
VTI give control to you to manage your personal data. You can request access, correction, updates or deletion of your personal information. You may unsubscribe from our marketing activity by clicking unsubscribe us from the bottom of our email or contacting us directly to remove you from our subscription listWe will keep your personal information accurate, and we allow you to correct or change your personal identifiable information through marketing@virtusindonesia.com